TL;DR
- Halfsies scores a cut as the lighter half divided by the heavier half, times 100.
- A straight cut across a triangle at half its height leaves the tip a quarter of the area. That scores 33.
- The true straight-across half is about 70.7 percent of the way down from the tip, because area goes with the square of size.
- Miss by 5 percent of the length you are measuring and the straight-across cut drops to about 75, while the corner-to-middle cut only drops to about 82. When you get to choose, cut from a corner.
Halfsies is my daily cutting game. You get three hand-drawn objects a day, draw one cut across each, and a scale weighs the two pieces by drawn area. Each cut scores the lighter half divided by the heavier half, times 100. Today the game's guides page, The Ledger, took on the plainest shape there is, the triangle, and the cut most people make on it is badly wrong.

Half the height is a quarter of the area
Cut straight across a triangle, parallel to its base, and the top piece is a smaller copy of the whole triangle. Copies shrink in two directions at once. Make one half as tall and it is also half as wide, so it holds half of a half: 25 percent. The base piece keeps 75. In Halfsies that is 25 divided by 75, a score of 33.
To give the tip piece half the area, its height has to be the square root of one half of the whole, about 0.707. So the straight-across half sits 70.7 percent of the way down from the tip, much nearer the wide end than the eye expects.
| Cut, share of height from tip | Tip piece | Base piece | Score |
|---|---|---|---|
| 50% | 25% | 75% | about 33 |
| 65.7% (5 points short) | 43% | 57% | about 76 |
| 70.7% | 50% | 50% | 100 |
| 75.7% (5 points long) | 57% | 43% | about 75 |
The forgiving cut
The guide's first method is the corner-to-middle cut: from any corner to the midpoint of the side across from it. Both pieces have the same height and equal bases, so they have equal area. What the guide does not dwell on is how each cut treats a slip.
On the corner-to-middle cut, the area on each side moves one for one with where you land on the far side. Land 5 percent of that side off the middle and the pieces are 55 and 45. That scores about 82.
On the straight-across cut, a slip of 5 percent of the height costs more, about 75 or 76. Near the right spot the tip piece's area grows about 1.4 times as fast as its height, so every bit of error is magnified. Same size of mistake, a worse score. If the shape lets you choose, cut from a corner.
The same thing in a turkey leg
Today's second guide is the Thanksgiving daily, Halfsies #149 on 26 November, and its opening cut is a turkey leg. A drumstick is a rough version of the same shape: a big rounded end and a thin bone. The guide puts the true half about 40 percent of the way down from the top of the meat, closer to the meat than the middle of the outline. It is the triangle lesson again. The wide end holds more than it looks like it should, so the half moves toward it.

The Halfsies ad diary #18 has the rest of the day, including the ad account, which spent nothing again. Diary #17 covers the cake layers guide, where a short, wide shape makes a small slip cost more.
The triangle guide is on The Ledger, and the game is at halfsies.jejestudios.com.